Rockstar: INXS--8/21, 8/23, 8/24
In advance: I know it’s long. There are 2 ½ hours of TV to talk about, just read it in three installments if you want.
Rockstar: INXS is better than American Idol. I said it. Mark Burnett is a better producer than anyone named Nigel and the fact is that it’s more entertaining to watch “lead singers” sing rock songs with a band then to watch vocal talents do Celine Dion. I really like Idol, hell, I even watch Canadian Idol just cuz the format is interesting. If you need proof just head over to the Canadian Idol website and notice that, with the exception of Aaron Walpole, none of their top 5 would be a shoe-in to even make it to Hollywood. You might also notice that none of the previous Canadian Idols are even half as famous as the Pink Power Ranger, which speaks volumes.
Regardless, I like both shows. I can acknowledge that some of the people on American Idol might be better singers than the cats on Rockstar, I don’t know anywhere near enough about anything musical to say. Nonetheless, rocking out with a sub-par voice to a song with a good rhythm and some power to it is more entertaining in my eyes than the voice of God belting Streisand. It is obvious that Burnett took some lessons and thematized a number of the issues which appear on Idol in the reality portion of Rockstar. Song selection actually happens, we hear something about alternatives, why someone would choose one song over another, and how the judges’ comments play into aforementioned decisions.
J.D. is the first black hat, to my knowledge, in music reality TV. You can hate on Nikki McKibben or Joshua Grayson, as we all did, but it was really just arbitrary dislike for them in opposition to whomever you loved. J.D. is objectively an ass and has been since he essentially accused the rest of the rockers of jumping on the INXS bandwagon during the show. There are really only four people on the show, coming into this week, still in contention, far as I can tell.
--J.D.—He called his friends out during the performance show, he ditched his group and Dave Navarro STILL LET HIM PERFORM ON HIS OWN, but still, he had some great original arrangements early on and INXS seems to buy the (self-created) hype by which he is the artiste in a house of derivatives.
--Mig—I would never have imagined myself writing this during the first weeks of the show, since he sucked at that point, to be honest. During the last 3-4 shows he has really come along and stole the show pretty decisively doing Frampton last week. I’m not sure he can keep it up, but if he maintains the trend it’s dangerous for the rest of the crew.
--Marty—You don’t think of this dude when you think rockstar, but he has been surprising. Both his performances of Nirvana and Franz Ferdinand would make the top 10 performances of the season and his scream is unlike anybody’s in the game.
--Jordis—Oh Jordis, lovely Jordis. I can’t pass up a chance to play up my hometown, but even if Jordis weren’t a quintessential St. Paul lady, she would have to be considered the frontrunner. She did Bowie with real soul, she did Nirvana without having to impersonate Cobain, and—I didn’t believe this one myself—she made HOOBASTANK not suck. A Jordis Unga fronted INXS would be one of the few start-to-finish reality victories.
The reality show: songwriting combined with song selection, creates a really interesting dynamic. The obvious point, that its gonna be hard to compete with the Rolling Stones and Aerosmith when it comes to producing legendary rock songs, still got a little lost on Suzie who was desperate for any chance to show those of us South of the border that she deserved it. Besides the fact that Mig’s songwriting skills may be in question, nothing much interesting happened by. As an aside, I should mention how much it sucks that they moved the 30 minute reality section to VH1 so they could show off another rerun of 2 ½ Men. Its Mondays during the summer, what the hell fills up your TiVo to the point that you can’t set the Season Pass?
The performance show: check out the big brains on Marty—compliment your judges, explain how thoroughly you know their history, then connect yourself both to them and the future. That right there is a quality answer to what could’ve been a painfully boring question. Suzie kicks of the show with a great performance of “Start Me Up” but songs aren’t the issue for the blonde Toronto-nian, America just doesn’t dig her. Heading over for some fellow-rocker accompaniment and finishing with a quick dip in the crowd was awesome and Dave/INXS concurred. If she could just stay out of the bottom three, she might have a shot. J.D was alright but he’s still the rock-singer equivalent of Satan’s violin in “The Devil Went Down to Georgia”—it’s pretty good, but you know you’re supposed to hate it. Deanna’s original song was pretty good, but since everyone is now convinced that she can only do bluesy rock, she’s in the same spot as Suzie.
Alright, now Ty has Jordis, Deanna, and Suzie singing back-up on “Proud Mary.” If Mig jumped off a bridge and INXS gave him an encore would everyone else in the cast do it too? Not that I’m complaining that I get to hear Jordis for a couple extra seconds, though you may want to consider not showcasing your competition during your performance. But yeah, he was good. Mig’s original song was not as good as Deanna and the critique offered during the reality show about how much harder the verses rocked in comparison to the chorus hung true. Apparently one of the camera-people decided they could emphasize this by shooting the crowd through Mig’s legs: there’s nothing better to frame the top of the screen than some Australian taint. Marty (who by the way 1. drastically underestimates how famous “I Alone” was and 2. looks like the heavy-metal Austin Scarlett, to quote my lovely wife) did Live and did it awesome. He does scream and I guess that isn’t INXS necessarily, but I dug it the same way Dave Navarro did before INXS shouted him down.
Jordis gets her own paragraph, cuz she’s special like that. She looks great, little newsy hat, the Steven Tyler props with the scarf around the mic. The song doesn’t start off as the best ever and she simply can’t pull off a note as high as was required for that bit. It was still really good and hopefully it won’t hurt her badly. Bottom three in the early balloting though, damn it.
The results show: Being an hour long this week gave them a chance to check in on the mansion at the opening of the results. Jordis knew she was not on top of her game. Besides that it was just Suzie, Ty, etc. over-generally speculating about the existence of the bottom three. Suzie got the encore, so Jordis’ chances of avoiding the bottom three are growing ever-slimmer. Hey, Reuben, Kelly, Carrie, they were all in the bottom three once, no reason to get worked up about it yet. After the encore they returned to the mansion and we got to see Jordis in turmoil a little bit longer, even guaranteeing she would make the bottom three. Marty continues to shine in answering Dave Navarro’s “tough questions,” so at least J.D. isn’t alone at the top this week.
Apparently everyone besides Suzie was in the bottom three at some point over the course of the voting, so I guess Jordis might escape due to the hard txting of her loyal fanbase. Even if she ends up singing INXS she’s taking it as well as possible. Ty is the first member of the bottom three and though he does “What You Need” pretty well he’s getting into a war of egos with J.D. Deanna is number two, no surprises. But Jordis manages to edge out Marty. A good sign of her support, but you gotta hope America doesn’t piss off the band by voting too many quality rockers into the bottom three. Marty rocked “Don’t Change” notably, so even if he deserved to be there, it wasn’t too dangerous.
Deanna went home. Couldn’t have been that tough a decision, given her company and their performances. Let’s hope the good guys aren’t fighting for their lives next week.
Rockstar: INXS is better than American Idol. I said it. Mark Burnett is a better producer than anyone named Nigel and the fact is that it’s more entertaining to watch “lead singers” sing rock songs with a band then to watch vocal talents do Celine Dion. I really like Idol, hell, I even watch Canadian Idol just cuz the format is interesting. If you need proof just head over to the Canadian Idol website and notice that, with the exception of Aaron Walpole, none of their top 5 would be a shoe-in to even make it to Hollywood. You might also notice that none of the previous Canadian Idols are even half as famous as the Pink Power Ranger, which speaks volumes.
Regardless, I like both shows. I can acknowledge that some of the people on American Idol might be better singers than the cats on Rockstar, I don’t know anywhere near enough about anything musical to say. Nonetheless, rocking out with a sub-par voice to a song with a good rhythm and some power to it is more entertaining in my eyes than the voice of God belting Streisand. It is obvious that Burnett took some lessons and thematized a number of the issues which appear on Idol in the reality portion of Rockstar. Song selection actually happens, we hear something about alternatives, why someone would choose one song over another, and how the judges’ comments play into aforementioned decisions.
J.D. is the first black hat, to my knowledge, in music reality TV. You can hate on Nikki McKibben or Joshua Grayson, as we all did, but it was really just arbitrary dislike for them in opposition to whomever you loved. J.D. is objectively an ass and has been since he essentially accused the rest of the rockers of jumping on the INXS bandwagon during the show. There are really only four people on the show, coming into this week, still in contention, far as I can tell.
--J.D.—He called his friends out during the performance show, he ditched his group and Dave Navarro STILL LET HIM PERFORM ON HIS OWN, but still, he had some great original arrangements early on and INXS seems to buy the (self-created) hype by which he is the artiste in a house of derivatives.
--Mig—I would never have imagined myself writing this during the first weeks of the show, since he sucked at that point, to be honest. During the last 3-4 shows he has really come along and stole the show pretty decisively doing Frampton last week. I’m not sure he can keep it up, but if he maintains the trend it’s dangerous for the rest of the crew.
--Marty—You don’t think of this dude when you think rockstar, but he has been surprising. Both his performances of Nirvana and Franz Ferdinand would make the top 10 performances of the season and his scream is unlike anybody’s in the game.
--Jordis—Oh Jordis, lovely Jordis. I can’t pass up a chance to play up my hometown, but even if Jordis weren’t a quintessential St. Paul lady, she would have to be considered the frontrunner. She did Bowie with real soul, she did Nirvana without having to impersonate Cobain, and—I didn’t believe this one myself—she made HOOBASTANK not suck. A Jordis Unga fronted INXS would be one of the few start-to-finish reality victories.
The reality show: songwriting combined with song selection, creates a really interesting dynamic. The obvious point, that its gonna be hard to compete with the Rolling Stones and Aerosmith when it comes to producing legendary rock songs, still got a little lost on Suzie who was desperate for any chance to show those of us South of the border that she deserved it. Besides the fact that Mig’s songwriting skills may be in question, nothing much interesting happened by. As an aside, I should mention how much it sucks that they moved the 30 minute reality section to VH1 so they could show off another rerun of 2 ½ Men. Its Mondays during the summer, what the hell fills up your TiVo to the point that you can’t set the Season Pass?
The performance show: check out the big brains on Marty—compliment your judges, explain how thoroughly you know their history, then connect yourself both to them and the future. That right there is a quality answer to what could’ve been a painfully boring question. Suzie kicks of the show with a great performance of “Start Me Up” but songs aren’t the issue for the blonde Toronto-nian, America just doesn’t dig her. Heading over for some fellow-rocker accompaniment and finishing with a quick dip in the crowd was awesome and Dave/INXS concurred. If she could just stay out of the bottom three, she might have a shot. J.D was alright but he’s still the rock-singer equivalent of Satan’s violin in “The Devil Went Down to Georgia”—it’s pretty good, but you know you’re supposed to hate it. Deanna’s original song was pretty good, but since everyone is now convinced that she can only do bluesy rock, she’s in the same spot as Suzie.
Alright, now Ty has Jordis, Deanna, and Suzie singing back-up on “Proud Mary.” If Mig jumped off a bridge and INXS gave him an encore would everyone else in the cast do it too? Not that I’m complaining that I get to hear Jordis for a couple extra seconds, though you may want to consider not showcasing your competition during your performance. But yeah, he was good. Mig’s original song was not as good as Deanna and the critique offered during the reality show about how much harder the verses rocked in comparison to the chorus hung true. Apparently one of the camera-people decided they could emphasize this by shooting the crowd through Mig’s legs: there’s nothing better to frame the top of the screen than some Australian taint. Marty (who by the way 1. drastically underestimates how famous “I Alone” was and 2. looks like the heavy-metal Austin Scarlett, to quote my lovely wife) did Live and did it awesome. He does scream and I guess that isn’t INXS necessarily, but I dug it the same way Dave Navarro did before INXS shouted him down.
Jordis gets her own paragraph, cuz she’s special like that. She looks great, little newsy hat, the Steven Tyler props with the scarf around the mic. The song doesn’t start off as the best ever and she simply can’t pull off a note as high as was required for that bit. It was still really good and hopefully it won’t hurt her badly. Bottom three in the early balloting though, damn it.
The results show: Being an hour long this week gave them a chance to check in on the mansion at the opening of the results. Jordis knew she was not on top of her game. Besides that it was just Suzie, Ty, etc. over-generally speculating about the existence of the bottom three. Suzie got the encore, so Jordis’ chances of avoiding the bottom three are growing ever-slimmer. Hey, Reuben, Kelly, Carrie, they were all in the bottom three once, no reason to get worked up about it yet. After the encore they returned to the mansion and we got to see Jordis in turmoil a little bit longer, even guaranteeing she would make the bottom three. Marty continues to shine in answering Dave Navarro’s “tough questions,” so at least J.D. isn’t alone at the top this week.
Apparently everyone besides Suzie was in the bottom three at some point over the course of the voting, so I guess Jordis might escape due to the hard txting of her loyal fanbase. Even if she ends up singing INXS she’s taking it as well as possible. Ty is the first member of the bottom three and though he does “What You Need” pretty well he’s getting into a war of egos with J.D. Deanna is number two, no surprises. But Jordis manages to edge out Marty. A good sign of her support, but you gotta hope America doesn’t piss off the band by voting too many quality rockers into the bottom three. Marty rocked “Don’t Change” notably, so even if he deserved to be there, it wasn’t too dangerous.
Deanna went home. Couldn’t have been that tough a decision, given her company and their performances. Let’s hope the good guys aren’t fighting for their lives next week.
